Where Have Our Songs Gone?

“They sang songs about freedom now we act like we don’t need ‘em…”- Mike Hicks “Where Have Our Songs Gone?”

Have you ever noticed that when some sort of tragic uprising is going on in the world that the first song most urban radio DJs reach for is Marvin Gaye’s “What’s Going On” which came out over 40 years ago? Now I’m not complaining about the song of course. It’s timeless much like all of Marvin Gaye’s music. I’d much rather hear his version than the pop star studded remake (sssshhh let’s not talk about that…nope, let’s not even).  But are we really that desperate for songs with meaning that we have to reach back over 40 years?

While pondering this, I issued a challenge on Facebook that went like this:  In light of recent tragedies regarding black men being senselessly murdered by police, if you were a DJ, could you put together an hour of music (about 15 songs) limited to only the following criteria:

* Is reflective of today’s societal  issues
* Performed by artists that have been on the Billboard charts within the past 3 years
*Encourages the listening audience towards peace, love, hope, self reflection and personal responsibility

And let’s not forget these stipulations as well:

* The song can’t contain the N-word or B-word used as a term of endearment because to me that’s a double negative (hey my challenge, my rules).
* You can only repeat an artist one time so no, playing The Roots and John Legend’s Wake Up album for an hour straight does not count.
*Insert Jeopardy music here*
After a total of 24 hours and 104 comments, we came up with a whopping SEVEN songs:1. Robin Thicke’s “New Generation” (Yes, “Blurred Lines” Robin Thicke. Don’t let the fluke of the success of that song fool you. He’s quite the songwriter actually.)
2. Erykah Badu’s “A.D. 2000”, a tribute to Amadou Diallo.
3. Jon Batiste and Stay Human’s “Social Music” (This was a new one to me. Glad I was introduced to his music.)
4. Aloe Blacc’s “Love is the Answer”.
5. Esperanza Spalding’s “Black Gold”
6. Janelle Monae’s “Sincerely Jane”
7. Mali Music’s “One”

7 songs in 24 hours.

Before I posted this challenge, I mentioned it to a friend who coincidentally found himself challenged on the way to work to find something to alleviate his frustration with current events, most specifically the uprising in Ferguson, Missouri.  He told me “I put on the Wake Up album but I got frustrated that I had nothing more to ‘soundtrack’ all of this to.”  Reminds me of something that John Mayer said in his song “Speak for Me”.

Show me something I can be
Play a song that I can sing
Make me feel as I am free
Someone come speak for me- “Speak for Me” John Mayer
Now if I were to say let’s pull some songs together from the sixties and seventies, we’d have no problem. Stevie Wonder, Curtis Mayfield, Marvin Gaye, The Staples Singers, Nina Simone and many others “spoke for us”.  They gave us a soundtrack for our frustrations and cries for freedom, peace and justice during a very tumultuous time in our country.  And it didn’t just stop with their music. Many of them used their platforms to speak out against injustice and to unify people to bring about change.  But if you look at then and fast forward to now?
Now they’re celebrating broken things
I don’t want a world of broken things
You can tell that something isn’t right
When all your heroes are in black and white-
“Speak for Me” John Mayer

Make no mistake, I am not picking on these artists of today.  Promising to be socially responsible is not a criteria when it comes to signing a recording contract no more than the guarantee that one is mentally stable.  I can’t imagine putting the pressure on some of the most popular artists today to suddenly become socially conscious.  I don’t even think that some of their record labels would allow it.  Besides, after witnessing some of the things that they can get arenas of people to repeat and co-sign that aren’t exactly socially responsible to begin with, I honestly don’t think it would be fair. We have indeed become a society that celebrates broken things.  So contrary to what you may think I was getting at with my challenge, my point was not that today’s artists need to change.  My point is music has become less and less about music and more and more about amusement.  What necessarily has caused this imbalance in our music?  I don’t have all of the answers but what I do have is a theory that may reveal a part of the problem.Besides producing socially conscious music that has stood the test of time as well as using their platform to bring about social change, there is one more thing that Marvin Gaye, Stevie Wonder, Nina Simone, The Staples Singers and Curtis Mayfield have in common: they all started in the church.

In a recent Time article, Questlove was quoted as saying something that up until I read him say it, I thought I was the only one that saw a correlation:

“…I don’t think it’s a mistake that a lot of of my favorite artists are coming from Down Under. A lot of them more soulful than what we’re dealing with now. When you think soul music and Aretha Franklin and the Baptist-born singer, that’s sort of an idea in the past. As black people, we’re really not in the church as we used to be, and that’s reflected in the songs now.”

He’s right. Black people, particularly young black people, are not in the church like they used to be and we need to ask ourselves why.   How can generations carry on the traditions of those that started out in church when they aren’t even there?
“Sing a new song, can we just sing a new song? Somewhere along the way we got it wrong…” Mali Music “One”
As I mentioned, one of the songs that we came up with during the challenge is “One” by Mali Music.  He along with many others have gone through so much criticism for going mainstream; a fight that seems so illogical to me in 2014.  Thankfully he has gotten past that criticism and has forged ahead to put out a very important, non-compromising album.  But what about those that could never get past the criticism? Those that have either let their talent stay and wither inside the four walls of the church or that have left the church altogether?  What about them? Could they be our missing voices?

Is the church to blame for shutting up the mouthpieces that we desperately need to speak to and for our culture? 

Yes it completely and undoubtedly is.

The way the church, and not just the black church but the church as a whole, has grossly mishandled the musical talents and gifts of its members is a shame and a sin rooted in both fear and elitism.  It’s across the board. I’ve heard too many stories about mainstream artists who are Christians that are criticized for what they do but no one minds them sending their tithe check in off of what it is that they do; too many stories about artists who have gotten preferential treatment because of what they do and have been pressured to be in the spotlight in their churches all the while their personal lives were falling apart with little to no recognition from pastoral leadership.  I’ve seen church musicians frustrated and completely resent the church and leave never to trust the church again while the pastors were too busy worrying about where they will find a replacement before Sunday than that person’s soul.  The Church needs to repent for how we have treated our “Davids” and our “Asaphs”.  It was never the intent of God to keep His children and their gifts within four walls.  If you truly believe in the word of God, if you believe that “where the spirit of the Lord is there is liberty,” don’t just let but SEND with your blessing outside the four walls of your church those with the Spirit that brings about liberty to convey that in their songs so that they can impact our culture. Who else to sing about love than those who believe in and walk in Love?  Who else to talk about the issues of life than those that have been given abundant life?

“Won’t you help me sing these songs of freedom…” Bob Marley “Redemption Song”

It’s time to wake all the way up, Church.  I am pleading with those in leadership to please acknowledge the fault and take the lead.  We’ve got to call our prodigal sons and daughters back and tell them that we were wrong. That the very gifts that we cursed or exploited were ones that could have been used to speak life at this very moment when our culture needs them the most.  We’ve got to train, equip, affirm, and intercede for those that have been called to mainstream music.  We must because here’s the thing: so much of the resistance from the church that musicians have faced when it comes to going mainstream is rooted in fear; fear that the industry will be too tempting and too much for them to take to the point that they will compromise their faith.  And it is all of those things… when you have to do it alone.  They shouldn’t have to do it alone. We need to stand with them.

So where have our songs gone? They’ve gone with the very ones we’ve shut out and shut down.  It’s time to invite them back in.  We need them now more than ever before.

“Mad, Real Mad, Joe Jackson”: How Should Hilltoppers Respond When It Seems Like The Church Just Doesn’t Get It?

“It hurts. You get angry. You get mad. You even feel disrespected because you don’t understand how people can be that *dumb* or unintentional in the name of Christ. That’s how you know it’s where you’re supposed to serve.”

This was a Facebook message I received from a friend of mine in ministry after one of my rants. I was fresh off a tantrum over an article condemning Mali Music for signing with Akon’s label. It misquoted something that he said regarding gospel music and while I can respect a difference of opinion (sometimes), I by no means can tolerate bad journalism. My friend understands all too well the frustration I feel when it comes to how some members of the church treat Christians who have been called to the mainstream. She is right. I get mad. I will admit that I sometimes get cussin’ mad; slammin’ doors, temperature rising, on the verge of tears but too angry to cry, mad. Because to me it’s a no brainer. It’s an open and shut case. However I need to accept that not everyone will agree, be angry yet sin not (Ephesians 4:26).

If you are a Christian artist in mainstream music (or a “Hilltopper” as I call them) I don’t doubt that you too have gotten angry, hurt and even cussin’ mad. You feel this deeper than I do. Because when someone is telling you that you are outside of God’s will by being outside of the church walls when it comes to your art, for the most part they are spewing damnation on what you know to be your calling. For a lot of people their calling and who they are are one and the same and thus they take this offense very personally. I want us to peel that offense off. You have to. You won’t survive within the church if you don’t.  I can already hear some of you now though…

“Oh I’m not a part of ‘the church’. I am a Christ follower/Red letter Christian/Follower of the Way, etc…”

The purpose of this ministry is not to foster an us vs. them mentality when it comes to those in the church with an opposing view on Christians in mainstream. You may not like some members of your family (the church), but the fact is you are a part of it. In regards to your relatives, you can’t say “the aunt that sends me money every year on my birthday is family but the uncle that gets drunk and belligerent at every funeral repass is not.” You can’t claim to be a Christ follower,ask him to break your heart for the things that break his, yet hate His bride. At the end of the day, we are all that bride. So how do we get along?

8 Finally, all of you, be like-minded, be sympathetic, love one another, be compassionate and humble. 9 Do not repay evil with evil or insult with insult. On the contrary, repay evil with blessing, because to this you were called so that you may inherit a blessing. 10 For, “Whoever would love life and see good days must keep their tongue from evil and their lips from deceitful speech. 11 They must turn from evil and do good; they must seek peace and pursue it. 12 For the eyes of the Lord are on the righteous and his ears are attentive to their prayer, but the face of the Lord is against those who do evil. 13 Who is going to harm you if you are eager to do good? 14 But even if you should suffer for what is right, you are blessed. “Do not fear their threats; do not be frightened.”15But in your hearts revere Christ as Lord. Always be prepared to give an answer to everyone who asks you to give the reason for the hope that you have. But do this with gentleness and respect, 16 keeping a clear conscience, so that those who speak maliciously against your good behavior in Christ may be ashamed of their slander. 17 For it is better, if it is God’s will, to suffer for doing good than for doing evil. 18 For Christ also suffered once for sins, the righteous for the unrighteous, to bring you to God. He was put to death in the body but made alive in the Spirit. – 1 Peter 3:8-17 NIV

One thing I am looking forward to is the “You Can’t Sing Secular Music Because…” series. It is my hope to help you respond in a the way that the aforementioned scripture encourages. To “always be prepared to give an answer to everyone who asks you to give the reason for the hope that you have. But do this with gentleness and respect, keeping a clear conscience, so that those who speak maliciously against your good behavior in Christ may be ashamed of their slander.” I am going to gather the most asked questions and comments that Hilltoppers receive about what they do and provide biblically based, practical answers. I tried to respond in this manner to the aforementioned article. In my most dignified way, I let them have it. I didn’t get personal. I didn’t call anyone an idiot. I gave a stern answer. Jesus gave stern answers that sometimes even seemed a little smart alecky because he knew what was in man’s heart. While we can often detect someone’s intentions, we don’t know their heart. We never know how a well informed, biblically based answer can change their thinking. I know this first hand because I used to be one of those people who gave Christians in mainstream or anyone who didn’t say Jesus in each and every song a very hard time. It was over a series of conversations I had with people who gave me stern answers with gentleness and respect, that my paradigm was shifted in such a way that I now have a heart for something that I was once vehemently against. You never know how close someone is to change so be careful. Giving someone who questions your calling being in the will of God a bad reaction may result in them feeling that you have proven them right.

If all were perfect, what should we have to suffer from others for God’s sake? But God has so ordained that we may learn to bear one another’s burdens for there is no man without fault… hence we must support one another, console one another, mutually help counsel, and advise, for the measure of every man’s virtue is best revealed in time’s of adversity- adversity that does not weaken a man but rather shows what he is- Excerpt from Imitation of Christ by Thomas A’Kempis